Seventy-five thousand chips approved for Alibaba. A hundred and fifty thousand for Tencent. And in one Nvidia application from April, more than forty thousand for a company reporters link to Megaspeed.
Those numbers came out of a House committee vote on Thursday, the same day California's attorney general served Nvidia with a subpoena. Welcome to Jensen Huang Investigation Watch. It's Friday, November 20. First, where things stand. Jensen Huang has admitted to Nvidia staff that he was unfaithful to his wife, and that's his own account. The claim that Alice Huang, a former Megaspeed executive, was gathering information for Beijing is an allegation, carried in news reports citing officials. China denies it, and Nvidia has said the contacts were ordinary customer dealings. The board's inquiry is still open with no findings. Jensen Huang and Alice Huang share a surname but aren't related, and nobody in this story faces criminal charges.
On the docket: the license records, California's subpoena, a shareholder suit that now reaches Alibaba, a report that the board isn't as united as it sounded, and a Democratic letter aimed at Howard Lutnick's family's firm. Tap follow so the next episode finds you.
The New York Times, as published in Singapore's Business Times:
The release also showed that Nvidia had submitted an application in April to sell more than 40,000 of its advanced H200 chips to a company tied to Megaspeed and Alice Huang, the executive who US intelligence has concluded was a Chinese asset who had an affair with the former Nvidia CEO.
That company is New Century Lettall Data Service, which the Times places in a network of Chinese firms with ties to Megaspeed and Alice Huang. The wider picture comes from the House Foreign Affairs Committee, which voted Thursday to release licensing data that export-control law normally keeps confidential. CNBC reports that Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security approved more than 879,000 AI chips for Chinese companies as of May, out of 3.4 million requested, and some approvals went to firms the Pentagon lists as Chinese military companies.
Two things to keep apart. Applying is not shipping. Nvidia spokesperson John Rizzo told the Times the company did not and will not ship an H200 to the Megaspeed-linked company, or to any other company, and that all its shipments were legal and government-authorized. And the line in that quote about what US intelligence has concluded is the Times' characterization. Alice Huang has not been charged, and Megaspeed denies wrongdoing.
Here's the part I'd circle. The committee singled out approvals for Maginfra, Beijing New Matrix and Aivres Systems. Chairman Brian Mast called the first two fake companies, and Times reporters found their China offices empty. And according to the committee, every Nvidia and AMD application said the transfer posed a low risk of diversion. That's customer vetting, in writing.
There's another side. Bernstein's Stacy Rasgon told CNBC that 879,000 is not that many, about one in four requested, which he read as a real process. Commerce says licensing decisions come from deliberation among several agencies. And Nvidia has since stopped shipping H200s to China, without saying why.
From California Attorney General Rob Bonta, in a statement his office released Thursday:
My office is investigating whether Nvidia or Jensen Huang’s actions resulted in China obtaining advanced chips or confidential information — and if Nvidia misled investors and the public about this risk, in violation of the law
On Tuesday, Bonta told Bloomberg Television that red flags had been raised and that his office was deciding whether to act. Two days later, it served an investigative subpoena. His office says what it gets back will help it evaluate whether Nvidia broke California law. His summary line: companies cannot mislead their investors.
On Wednesday we said he hadn't opened an investigation yet. Now he has, and a subpoena is a demand for information, not a polite request. But it's still an investigative step. It isn't a lawsuit, it isn't a charge, and it doesn't find anything. One more note: the release describes Alice Huang as an alleged spy. That's the attorney general's wording, and no charges have been filed against her.
Count the disclosure probes now. There's the civil SEC inquiry the Wall Street Journal reported Tuesday, citing people familiar with it, and now a state one. Both are asking what shareholders were told. Investing.com puts the stock down thirty percent this month. That's the compliance discount I keep talking about.
Bonta is also asking whether chips or confidential information reached China. The board says it has no reason to believe secrets were compromised. That's a stated position, and California is now testing it.
Jonathan Stempel, reporting for Reuters:
According to a proposed class action filed in Manhattan federal court, Alibaba inflated its share price by knowingly and materially understating in its 2024, 2025 and 2026 annual reports the risks that actual or suspected export control violations could harm its business.
So the litigation has moved to the customer side. Alibaba shareholder Withida Bihan filed Thursday, for holders of Alibaba's American depositary shares from May 23, 2024 through November 11 of this year. Chief executive Eddie Wu is also a defendant. The complaint says Alibaba shares fell fourteen percent over four days last week on reports about its ties to Alice Huang and Megaspeed, including that it had become Megaspeed's dominant customer.
This is the plaintiff's version, and nothing has been tested in court. Alibaba didn't immediately respond to Reuters. It also connects to something we covered Thursday: The Information's report, based on unnamed sources, that Nvidia's sales team introduced Alibaba to Alice Huang in 2022. That's still a report, not a finding. Megaspeed is described here as suspected, and it denies wrongdoing.
Meanwhile Wu said Thursday that Alibaba is still on track for a hundred billion dollars in outside cloud revenue by 2030. Investors apparently want the export-control risk spelled out before they buy that number.
Reed Albergotti and Rohan Goswami, in a Semafor exclusive published Tuesday night:
Despite Nvidia’s proclamation Tuesday that it didn’t plan to bring ousted CEO Jensen Huang back to the chipmaker, a faction of board members is pushing for his return, according to people familiar with the matter.
We hadn't gotten to this one, and it cuts against what we led with on Wednesday. Semafor's sources say Jensen Huang spoke with at least one director about coming back. That conversation came before the earnings report and before his public statement saying he'd be honored to return. Semafor puts the holdouts at three directors. The rest are reportedly narrowing the search, and Arm's Rene Haas and Marvell's Matt Murphy have both been considered.
Weigh the sourcing. The chair, Harvey Jones, spoke on the record and by name. Semafor has unnamed people. Both can be accurate, because the board voted unanimously to accept the resignation, and a few directors wanting him back later is a separate thing. Spokespeople for Jensen Huang and Nvidia declined to comment. Semafor doesn't name the three. For me the test is whether any of them sit on the independent committee overseeing the inquiry into him, and we don't know.
Semafor says Haas worries about the optics of taking the job amid calls for Huang's return, and Murphy's company is mid-merger with Lumentum. A divided board, a founder who wants back in, and a shortlist with asterisks. That's key-person risk, and this board still hasn't answered it.
Reuters, as published by Al Jazeera:
In the five-page letter dated November 17, House Democrats notified Brandon Lutnick, chairman of Cantor Fitzgerald and Howard Lutnick’s son, that they are requesting information to ascertain whether “any actions or decisions by Secretary Lutnick concerning export controls, enforcement measures, or national security policies may have been improperly influenced by Cantor Fitzgerald’s holdings or business interests”.
The letter comes from Jamie Raskin, Gregory Meeks and Sydney Kamlager-Dove. At its center is one question: did Cantor's financial exposure have anything to do with Megaspeed staying off the Entity List? Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has already said four agencies wanted Megaspeed on that list and Commerce, which makes the call, didn't add it.
Here are the denials. Commerce says the secretary has complied with his ethics agreement and divested all his interests in Cantor. Cantor says it holds no material proprietary position in Nvidia and plays no role in export decisions. On posture, this is a letter from ranking members asking for information. It isn't a committee subpoena, and nobody has found a conflict.
The calendar keeps filling up, though. On Wednesday, Senate Banking chair Tim Scott told CNBC that Jensen Huang and Lutnick have both agreed to appear, hopefully before Christmas. His original letters asked for Thursday, December 3 for Huang and Thursday, December 10 for Lutnick, and the committee hasn't confirmed either date.
According to the Times, Foreign Affairs also plans hearings next month with Lutnick and his deputy Jeffrey Kessler. Jensen Huang's closed-door transcribed interview with the three House committees is still set for Tuesday, December 1. There's still no subpoena and no sworn testimony.
If the chip-export side of this has you thinking about the bigger AI picture, check out our sister show, AI Safety Daily. Every weekday it covers AI alignment, model evaluations, emerging risks and governance: what changed, what the evidence says, and why it matters.
That's the week. We're back Monday, November 23. We'll be looking for Nvidia's delayed quarterly filing, any reply to California's subpoena, and firm dates from Senate Banking. One last reminder: two people named Huang, no family connection, and no criminal charges against anyone. This has been Jensen Huang Investigation Watch, a Lantern Podcast.
Have a good weekend. See you Monday.