Twenty-five years after LVMH started quietly buying Hermès stock, a Paris judge wants psychiatrists to examine the man who says his piece of it was taken from him. You're listening to Fashion Business Daily, and it's Monday, November 16. After the Hermès heir story, Dillard's shows how to grow one percent and still beat Wall Street, and LuisaViaRoma gets sold to the only bidder who turned up.
Tassilo Hummel and David Gauthier-Villars, reporting for Reuters:
The judge has ordered a team of psychiatrists to check whether Puech, 83, could be mentally impaired, the two people familiar with the investigation said, adding that any finding showing the heir was vulnerable and taken advantage of could potentially lower the bar for criminal liability in the probe into his missing fortune.
Reuters published this as an exclusive on Friday, November 13, and it rests on two people with direct knowledge of the decision. Nobody involved is confirming it on the record. Prosecutors, Puech's spokespeople and LVMH all declined to comment. Puech says his roughly 6 percent stake in Hermès disappeared, and he says he only found out in 2022, after he cut ties with his Swiss wealth manager, Eric Freymond. Reuters puts the shares at about 9 billion dollars at today's prices. And the legal hook matters here. French law has a specific offense called abuse of weakness, the one people know from the Liliane Bettencourt case. If psychiatrists find Puech was vulnerable, the bar for criminal liability could drop. So this isn't just a medical exam. It could decide what charges are even possible. Let's be careful about who is accused of what. Prosecutors have focused on Freymond, who died in 2025 and denied wrongdoing, and on Alexandre Montavon, the Swiss lawyer who advised LVMH on its stakebuilding in the 2000s. Montavon was placed under investigation in May, denies wrongdoing, and has appealed this cognitive-check order. LVMH and Bernard Arnault are defendants in Puech's civil suit seeking 14 billion euros, but neither has been named a formal suspect in the criminal case. LVMH's position, from a June court filing, is that it worked with Freymond to build Hermès shares but any purchase of Puech's shares would have been unintentional. Meanwhile Reuters reported in September that LVMH paid Freymond at least 20 million dollars in commissions and fees. That's a lot of money to pay someone whose biggest contribution was supposedly an accident. That's his read. LVMH denies it ever tried to get Puech's shares through those arrangements. For Hermès itself, nothing changes operationally. This is about a fight LVMH ended in 2014, when it agreed to unwind a stake of up to 23 percent, and that fight still hasn't gone away.
William T. Dillard II, in Dillard's third-quarter results release:
We achieved 1% sales growth on top of last year’s 3% increase, supporting a strong 45.3% retail gross margin.
Dillard's reported after the close on Thursday, November 12, for the quarter ended October 31. The company-reported figures: total retail sales up 1 percent to 1.418 billion dollars, comparable stores also up 1 percent, and net income of 130.9 million dollars, or 8.38 a share, against 8.31 a year ago. Chain Store Age says analysts expected 7.80, so a clear beat on earnings, while Seeking Alpha points out that net sales barely moved. Look at what's actually selling, though. Men's, home, accessories, juniors and kids up moderately. Shoes flat. Ladies' apparel down slightly. For a department store, that's the category that's supposed to bring people in, and it's the one going backwards. Margin says the same thing. Retail gross margin held at exactly 45.3 percent, but it slipped in ladies' apparel and fell moderately in juniors' and children's. Operating expenses rose to 30.3 percent of sales on higher payroll, and inventory ended the quarter up 4 percent while sales grew 1. Inventory growing four times faster than sales going into the holidays. Either they're confident or there's a clearance rack coming in January. Also check the year-to-date number before quoting it. Net income for the first 39 weeks rose to 479.1 million dollars from 366.5 million, but that includes a 104.1 million dollar pre-tax gain from settling a card interchange-fee lawsuit and 37.2 million in refunded IEEPA tariffs. Strip those out and the improvement is much smaller. For comparison, Investing.com reports Macy's posted a third-quarter loss of 19 cents a share, a cent worse than the analyst estimate, on revenue of 4.67 billion dollars, in line with consensus. So the most boring department store in America is the one making money. Dillard's doesn't chase anything, and right now that's working.
Martino Carrera, writing in WWD:
The consideration is made up of 4 million euros in cash and 14.8 million euros in assumed liabilities, including selected bank and employee obligations, as well as certain tax and social security liabilities.
So the headline price of 18.83 million euros for LuisaViaRoma is mostly debt being taken on, with just 4 million in cash. That price equals the starting bid set by the Florence court, because nobody else bid. Montenapo Daily reports the deadline for competing offers ran out on Sunday, November 8. Arav, the owner of John Richmond and Silvian Heach, had said in October it was looking at the file, but it never submitted an offer. The buyer is ATO, led by Paolo Corinaldesi, the former Woolrich and Filson CEO, alongside two branches of the Marzotto family and a few other Italian industrialists. Their newco, LVR Srl, has leased and run the business since July, so the court is just making it official. There's an earn-out of up to 3 million euros if cumulative EBITDA for 2026 through 2029 tops 23 million. Back in July, Corinaldesi told WWD he expected sales of 120 to 140 million euros in 2027. That's his projection, not a reported number. Montenapo Daily says the new company keeps 157 jobs, down from more than 200 before the crisis, and the closed New York store is left out of the deal. About 90 percent of revenue is online, per Montenapo, and the Via Roma flagship becomes a space for talent, special projects and niche brands. Right instinct. Multibrand e-tailers all sell the same labels, so taste is the only edge. One more link for regular listeners. The previous controlling owner was Style Capital, which exited in December 2025. That's the same fund we covered on November 3, when it took control of N°21. It left a struggling e-tailer and bought into a designer label.
Quick favor before we go. If this show saves you from reading three trade papers before your coffee, take thirty seconds and rate or review it in your podcast app. That's honestly the main way new listeners find a show this specific.
That's Monday on Fashion Business Daily. David Jones creditors meet tomorrow, and we'll be back then. And I'll be watching whether anyone at Dillard's starts worrying about that inventory. Fashion Business Daily is part of the Lantern Podcast family. See you Tuesday.