Here's a question for every developer with a project stuck behind an environmental lawsuit. What happens when the window to sue shrinks from years to 150 days?
As of Thursday, that's a question for the House, not the Senate.
This is The Data Center Daily for Friday, November 20th. I'm Sarah, and Matt is with me. Four stories: the Senate passing its permitting reform bill, ratepayer advocates from seven states asking PJM to push back its December capacity auction, new building-level data on when data center construction actually starts, and the president putting a rough timeline on Blackwell sales to China.
Tap follow so the next episode finds you.
Latitude Media, on Thursday's vote:
BAAJA would set faster timelines for federal agencies to review and approve environmental permits for a long list of energy projects, as well as shorten the window parties have to sue from years to 150 days.
We followed this bill on the 10th and again on the 13th, when it was headed for a full vote. That vote came Thursday: the Bipartisan Affordability and American Jobs Act passed the Senate 62 to 33. Beyond the shorter litigation window, Latitude says it would make it harder for courts to block projects under NEPA, the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act. Construction could continue even if a court finds a federal environmental review deficient, and states and Tribes would have less authority to deny projects over water pollution.
That last piece is the one transmission developers want most. Pipeline people too, and that's exactly why the climate movement split over it. Latitude says four key senators made changes in recent weeks to address concerns from Tribes, investor-owned utilities and environmentalists. That was enough to bring the Edison Electric Institute and Evergreen Action on board.
It didn't hold everyone. Nearly every Democrat on the Environment and Public Works Committee voted no, Sheldon Whitehouse being the exception as a lead negotiator. Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada voted no as well, partly over provisions narrowing Tribes' consultation rights on cultural and sacred sites.
The data center angle is all over the supporters' pitch. They argue passing it now delivers for voters who want lower bills and want data centers to pay for their energy costs. Lisa Murkowski on the floor called it the best option not only for now but likely for years to come.
Now it goes to the House. Latitude reports a coalition of more than 100 moderate Democrats warming to it. Representatives Jared Huffman and Rashida Tlaib are opposed and argue the party should wait until next year, when it controls Congress. Supporters counter that President Trump has two years left and would likely veto a Democratic version.
Martin Heinrich's argument is the one to watch in the House. He says litigation has stopped bad projects, but the current system slows good ones too, and a lot of clean energy is sitting in congested queues. Rhodium Group's forecast, per Latitude, has the bill accelerating long-haul transmission. If that's right, the data center waiting on new high-voltage wires is the real beneficiary here, not whoever's building the next gas turbine.
Ethan Howland, senior reporter at Utility Dive:
State ratepayer advocates have joined the PJM Interconnection’s market monitor in calling for the grid operator to delay its upcoming capacity auction over concerns it could threaten the reliability of the bulk power system and cause consumers to pay billions in unnecessary costs driven by data centers.
The auction is the base residual auction for the 2029/30 delivery year, set for December 9th through the 15th. In a letter sent Wednesday, advocates from seven states asked PJM's board to postpone it until data center loads, in their words both real and speculative, come out of the load forecast, and to run a separate reliability backstop procurement for those large loads.
Look at who signed. Ohio Consumers' Counsel, the Delaware Public Advocate, West Virginia's Consumer Advocate, Maryland's Office of People's Counsel, Pennsylvania's Office of Consumer Advocate, New Jersey's Division of Rate Counsel, the Illinois Attorney General's office and the Illinois Citizens Utility Board. That's the people who answer to the ratepayers, all on one page.
They're leaning on the market monitor. We covered Monitoring Analytics' November 12th report on the 13th: 29.4 billion dollars of capacity cost increases from data center load so far, and a December auction it expects to clear at the cap and add another 5 to 10 billion. The monitor says the forecast includes data centers that have been canceled or are unlikely to reach projected levels.
PJM isn't budging. Spokesman Jeffrey Shields told Utility Dive the auction has an established price cap as a safeguard, the system urgently needs capacity, and postponing this close could destabilize the market and raise the risk of power interruptions. Fine. But the cap is 337.83 dollars a megawatt-day, and the monitor's whole point is that speculative load guarantees you hit it.
Two procedural facts. PJM's board can't delay on its own; it would need FERC approval. And the advocates want a written answer by Monday, November 23rd. They also flagged that PJM planned to publish final planning parameters on the 19th, which may drop canceled or delayed projects from the demand curve, though they say updating the forecast isn't enough.
They cite the January statement of principles from PJM and the 13 governors, that large-load forecasts be real and verified. Hard to argue against your own press release.
Blockspace, on new construction data:
According to building-level data released Tuesday by Cleanview, US developers began vertical construction in the third quarter on 8.4 GW of data-center power capacity at 65 buildings.
That's 28 percent below the second quarter's record 11.7 gigawatts across 96 buildings, and the first quarter-on-quarter decline since early 2025. It was still the third-highest quarter in Cleanview's series and 55 percent above a year earlier. Then October rebounded to 4.6 gigawatts across 33 buildings, second only to June.
And three campuses carried October. Nscale started 720 megawatts at its Monarch campus in West Virginia for Anthropic. Related Digital started 461 at Stargate Michigan for Oracle and OpenAI. Crusoe started 450 at Abilene for Microsoft. That's 1,631 megawatts, about 35 percent of the month. One 700 megawatt building can swing a whole quarter.
Definitions matter here. A start is when foundation and steel work begins, not land clearing. It measures facility power capacity, not IT load or completions, and it lumps hyperscale, colocation, enterprise and crypto mines together, so it doesn't isolate AI. Within those limits: 38 gigawatts of starts in the twelve months through October, double the prior twelve, 58 under construction and 65 operating.
Founder Michael Thomas says if November and December match October, the fourth quarter sets a record around 14 gigawatts. He also says one month doesn't make a trend. I appreciate a guy who hedges his own headline.
Put it next to this week's capex cuts and it's less contradictory than it sounds. Blockspace notes SemiAnalysis's sequence: leasing comes first, then debt, then construction, and most of the debt behind this year's leases is already raised. The risk is earlier in the pipeline.
Which is where politics lives. A governor or governor-elect in nine states has promised or imposed a pause, and those states hold 41 percent of planned US capacity in Cleanview's data. Most of those pledges hit projects that haven't broken ground, including the ones caught in the Texas permit freeze. Steel in the ground is safe. Paper isn't.
From The Economic Times:
“In two years or three years, I would, if I were here, I would say, go ahead. You can now sell Blackwells because they’ll have something else,” he said in an interview with Fox News from Shenzhen, China.
That's President Trump, in remarks Bloomberg reported on the 19th, saying the US could let Nvidia sell Blackwell processors to China once newer chips surpass them. Tom Whitfield at Chip Dispatch notes he also predicted the current generation will be obsolete in another year, and calls the remarks a direction, not an authorization. No rules changed.
Do the calendar math. Two to three years lands around late 2028 or 2029. Bloomberg points out the term ends January 2029. So this is a timeline that may belong to somebody else.
And Congress is moving the other way. Senators Jim Banks and Elizabeth Warren have advanced the AI Overwatch Act into the defense authorization negotiations, which typically wrap in December. It would block exports of the most advanced AI processors to countries of concern for at least 18 months, and require more Commerce certifications before lesser chips get licenses. Bloomberg reported the bill gained momentum after Jensen Huang left as CEO, since he had opposed tighter controls.
For Nvidia's numbers, close to nothing changes. As we covered Wednesday, the roughly 130 billion dollar fourth-quarter guide already assumes zero China data center revenue, and licensed Hopper shipments stopped after 2.4 billion dollars of sales last quarter. Chip Dispatch puts that at about 2.1 percent of revenue.
The piece that reaches further: per FinanceFeeds, TSMC and Samsung have suspended certain shipments to Chinese customers while they seek licenses under new Commerce Department rules covering manufacturing and packaging arrangements. Same direction as the transceiver curb we covered yesterday.
So the policy signal points both ways at once. The White House talks about selling old chips later, Congress wants a statute, and Commerce is tightening the supply chain right now. If you're planning capacity around China demand, plan around the statute.
If you've got a read on the PJM auction fight or the House math on permitting, we'd like to hear it. Write to datacenterdaily at lantern podcasts dot com.
Especially if you're one of the people who'd have to file the 150-day lawsuit. Or defend against it.
We're back Monday, November 23rd, the same day those seven advocates want PJM's board to answer them in writing.
And Southwest Power Pool's show-cause filing is due today, so we'll have that too.
That's The Data Center Daily, a Lantern Podcast. Have a good weekend, from both of us.